Demonstrates exceptionally logical and organized thinking. Show respect for differing ideas, thoughts, and valuesno put downs or. The assessment for wwii is a socratic seminar, where you will argue a position on 1 of 5 different positions regarding the dropping of the bomb. Prior to the discussion, the teacher will select an appropriate text. Without warning, drop an atomic bomb on a japanese city as soon as possible. A major goal of this class is to develop the students skill to analyze a text, then demonstrate that analysis through speaking. This rubric may also prove useful to students who are evaluating other students or reflecting on their own participation. Drop the bomb on an unpopulated area to demonstrate its destructive capabilities. Here are the general guidelines for participating in a socratic seminar and a rubric. Youll need to cut each packet page in half after you print them out, as each booklet you give to the students is only half a page.
They can also lose points if they disrupt the discussion. Dont try long texts or long seminars at first, build gradually. Using resources and tools like the ones below, educators at kipp king collegiate high school focus on honing critical thinking skills across all subjects. Here are the general guidelines for participating in a socratic seminar and a rubric that will be used to assess your participation. The outsiders socratic seminar and rubric by the redhaired. Make a big deal about how important socratic seminars are for the skills they teach. Several areas of discussion guidelines need development.
You will lose points if you are talking while others are trying to score points. Socratic seminar will be assessed using a basic avid rubric. Level i is comprehension questions that help you understand the story. Socratic circles seeks to give the student the opportunity to demonstrate his her level of understanding of a text and the. Socratic seminar rubric for individual participants.
Socratic seminar rubric i use this rubric to grade small group discussions called socratic seminars. Provides solid analysis, without prompting, to move the conversation forward. This process encourages divergent thinking rather than convergent. Lafs scale and rubric for speaking and listening this addresses presentations, socratic seminars, and group work.
Lafs scale and rubric for speaking and listening this. As a grader, you can subtract points if people do not follow the. A rubric for evaluating a socratic seminar discussion is provided in the assessment section. Global history i expositoryinformative essay rubric. Socratic circle rubric email utica community schools. Steps for socratic seminars tangipahoa parish school board. Participant, through his or her comments, demonstrates a deep knowledge of the text and the question. Provides relevant and insightful comments, makes new connections. Share a socratic seminar anchor chart, located in kipp wheatley student handout files and socratic seminar lesson appendices. The rubric for evaluating classroom discussions, as well as the socratic seminar fishbowl discussion partner evaluation could be used for this purpose. Socratic seminar rubric text preparationreading and annotation of text engagementparticipation in discussion and ontask use of textsupport of ideas with text. Evaluate the students research presentation employing the following rangescored criteria best is on right. Socratic seminar rubric exemplary proficient partially proficient developing comments analysis and reasoning clearly references text to support reasoning. You read and annotate the article that we will be discussing.
In a socratic seminar, participants seek deeper understanding of complex ideas in the text through rigorously thoughtful dialogue, rather than by memorizing bits of information. Socratic seminar rubric does not meet standard 1 approaching standard 2 meets standard 3 exceeds standard 4 conduct displays little respect for the learning process. The text must be complex and rich in ideas that promote thinking and discussion. You should highlight important information throughout the article. Bring notes and bookmarked pages that are relevant to the discussion. Student states ideas with relevant supporting evidence from several of the following. Guidelines for socratic seminar facilitators your task is not to make participants cover the topic but to help them use their minds well. The quality of the seminar is diminished when participants speak without preparation. Lastly, the file contains the socratic circle rubric. Development of math reasoning collaboratively by ryan higgins, ph. Students are expected to articulate their own thoughts as well as listen and respond to others in the the group.
Socratic seminar guidelines before the socratic seminar read and prepare your text before the seminar using the critical reading process. Socratic seminar rubric for individual participants name. Check off the description that best applies to your subjects performance in todays socratic seminar. During the seminar, some teachers reserve an empty hotseat for those in the outer circle who really. Readings in literature, history, science, math, health, and philosophy or works of art or music may be used. What types of people moved in the different colonial areas. Sep 02, 2016 the socratic seminar is one of the best teaching techniques for engaging students in critical thinking and meaningful discussion of a text. Participant, through his or her comments, demonstrates a deep knowledge of. Pdf files can be viewed on a wide variety of platforms both as a browser plugin or a standalone application with adobes free acrobat reader program. Socratic circle rubric for ib entrance testing adapted from.
Socratic seminars are a teaching tool that empowers students and can turn up the thought level around any topic. Socratic circle rubric engaged in discussion and stays ontask supports ideas with references to the text listens respect. Total points 20 points possible in each section 100 number of comments how often did you speak. Intel, the intel logo and the intel education initiative are trademarks of intel. Demonstrates thoughtful consideration of the topic. Socratic seminars grading rubric a major goal of this class is to develop the students skill to analyze a text, then demonstrate that analysis through speaking and writing. Socratic seminar observation checklist literacy cookbook. They will make a check each time their partner speaks, and paraphrase a meaningful comment their partner made. The intensified socratic seminar assessment guide edutopia. During the smackdown, they will earn points for using discussion skills.
Student seminar evaluation rubric student presenter. A socratic seminar is a method to try to understand information by creating a dialectic class in regards to a specific text. In a socratic seminar, participants seek deeper understanding complex ideas in the text through rigorously thoughtful dialogue. A socratic seminar is method to try to understand information by creating a dialectic in class in regards to a specific text. The socratic seminar is used in many expeditionary learning classrooms to. When you print out the file, youll see packet a on the top half of the sheet, packet b on the bottom half, and then the rubric as the last page of the file. Show the students the rubric what about students that dont speak as much. You are a colearner, not an authority on right answers.
Resources and downloads for teaching critical thinking. College students participate in seminars, and this practiceboth the discussions and the notetaking a skill college students must have but many struggle withwill help them in the future. Powered by create your own unique website with customizable templates. Encourage students to identify personal goals, such as, today, i will focus on responding to what my. Did the individual participate voluntarily, or did heshe need to be prompted. Existentialism socratic seminar participation rubric. Participants in a socratic seminar respond to one another. Socratic seminar scoring guide rubric editable teaching. Fostering critical and creative thinking in middle and high school. Dialogue is exploratory and involves the suspension of biases and prejudices. This lesson will provide three rubrics for assessing seminar participation. The outsiders socratic seminar and rubric by the red.
I develop four sets of themebased, philosophical questions for the novel, poem, or short story and divide up the students in the class into the four groups. President lincoln and the suspension of habeas corpus. Each of the following criteria are worth 10 points. Offers some analysis, but needs prompting from others.
1497 539 1111 1004 1307 88 1238 1245 1077 1407 1465 662 414 266 104 1150 1132 1138 382 962 55 207 907 801 345 618 706 402 1464 64 1114 1122 461 97 193 1141 375 1060 464 885